Best Pizza in Custer

Q: Where are you located?

We are located in Custer, SD at 904 Mt Rushmore Rd

Handmade Pizza in the midst of the Black Hills

Featured

Fresh Ingredients Prepared and Sliced in House, Every Day, Since 2012

Made-to-order pies with bold, unexpected toppings — crafted by the family behind Pizza Mill, who've been doing this right in Custer, SD for over a decade.

Order Now

Mill Favorites Worth the Drive

From the Gyro Pizza loaded with tzatziki and fresh veggies to the Pickle Pizza and Ultimate Reuben -our signature pies are what people come back for.

See the Full Menu

Take N' Bake Pizza

Order fresh, bake at camp or home on your own schedule. Available in medium, XL, gluten-free, and cheesy bread.

Learn More

Fresh from Our Kitchen

Find Us in Custer, SD

We're on Mt. Rushmore Road- one block east of Lynn's Dakotamart. Right across from Dollar General. We are just a few minutes from the hotels and many other guest locations in the Custer area. 📍 904 Mt Rushmore Rd, Custer, SD 57730 📞 (605) 673-3306 🕒 Mon – Sat: 11 AM – 8 PM Sun: Closed

Get Directions

What our guests are saying

Had a wonderful experience at Pizza Mill. The staff are incredibly friendly. We ordered a gluten-free pizza for my wife, and it was phenomenal (I ate half of it, and it's probably the best GF crust I've ever tasted). My daughter really liked her personal cheese pizza as well. Highly recommend checking them out!

Ryan R.

The Towering Timber we got yesterday was simply outstanding, as we've become addicted to it. The crust was exactly as we prefer, slightly thick and able to support all the great ingredients piled on top of it. Amaze, Amaze, Amaze. Thank you for listening to me.

Tom W.

Very impressed with this place. The pizza was great, wings fantastic and service was perfect. Well done, if I’m ever around here again I’ll be back.

Trevor B.

Best pizza in Custer and Rapid City. As a seasonal worker I’ve tried pretty much every pizza spot around, these guys are 100% the best, don’t think twice about it!

Abraham G.

Pizza Mill Rewards

Join our rewards program, earn points every time you order online and redeem your points for free food.

Join Pizza Mill Rewards

FAQs

Our Specialty 🍕
We are widely known for our out-of-the-box specialty pizza creations, our local-favorite Salads, Sandwiches, Wings, Calzones and Cheesy Bread. We bake our pizzas to order, in our brick ovens.
We Serve the Following Areas 🛵
We serve the following areas: Custer, Berne, Fourmile, Sanator, Vestal Springs, Blue Bell, Oreville, Nihart, Custer County, Reno, and Pringle but our delivery area is a 4 mile radius of Custer.
I Need to Feed a Large Group, Can You Help? 👪
Yes! We would love to help! Though we can only seat 20 people indoors and 24 people outdoors on a first-come, first-served basis, we are more than happy to fulfill large orders.

A Custer Family's Labor of Love Since 2012

Family-owned in Custer, SD since 2012, Pizza Mill was started by our parents and is now proudly run by the second generation. From helping out as kids to taking over as owners, we're dedicated to hard work, integrity, and serving our community. Step inside and you will find something for everyone: our famous topping combinations, huge calzones, build-your-own pizzas, fresh salads, pasta, gluten free options, and a rotating lineup of local craft beer. Ask us about our Take N' Bake pizzas too, made to order and packed up for you to bake at home whenever you are ready. When the weather is nice, our pet-friendly patio is the perfect spot to settle in. We truly appreciate your business, and we hope you leave feeling like part of the family.